The Case for Prohibiting Convicted Felons from National Ballots

The Case for Prohibiting Convicted Felons Without Restored Voting Rights from National Ballots

The integrity of America’s electoral process is the cornerstone of its democracy. Candidates for public office are expected to exemplify the highest standards of ethics and accountability. However, the inclusion of individuals convicted of serious crimes—especially those who have not yet been sentenced or completed their sentences—on national ballots raises questions about public trust and the credibility of the electoral process. It is time to address this gap with clear and enforceable legislation.

The Problem: Felons Without Accountability on Ballots

Under current laws, there is often no universal restriction preventing individuals convicted of felonies from appearing on national election ballots. This includes those who:

• Have lost their voting rights: Many states strip convicted felons of the right to vote while they serve their sentence, yet these same individuals can sometimes still appear on ballots.

• Have not been sentenced: Candidates under indictment or awaiting sentencing may exploit the legal process to run for office, even as their status remains unresolved.

• Have not completed their sentences: Those still serving time, whether incarcerated or on probation/parole, may still qualify to run in some jurisdictions.

This situation creates a glaring inconsistency: citizens are denied the right to vote while candidates convicted of felonies and stripped of voting rights can seek public office.

The Need for Legislation

To ensure the credibility of elections and restore public confidence, legislation is needed to bar convicted felons from appearing on national ballots unless they meet specific criteria: they have either completed their sentences or been exonerated, and their voting rights have been fully restored.

Key Arguments for the Legislation

1. Preserving Public Trust in GovernmentAllowing individuals convicted of serious crimes to run for national office undermines public faith in the democratic process. Voters deserve candidates who uphold ethical standards and demonstrate a commitment to the rule of law.

2. Restoring Consistency and AccountabilityIf a convicted felon has lost their voting rights, they should not simultaneously have the privilege of running for public office. This legislation ensures that eligibility for office aligns with the fundamental rights and responsibilities of citizenship.

3. Ensuring Fair RepresentationCandidates for public office must represent the interests and values of their constituents. Allowing individuals still entangled in legal obligations to serve undermines the credibility of their ability to govern effectively.

4. Deterring Abuse of the Legal SystemBy restricting ballot access to those who have completed their sentences or been exonerated, the legislation prevents individuals from exploiting their candidacy to delay or avoid sentencing, probation, or parole.

Proposed Legislative Framework

This legislation would:

1. Disqualify candidates who are convicted felons and have lost their voting rights until they have:

   • Completed their sentences, including incarceration, probation, parole, and restitution.

   • Had their voting rights restored through appropriate legal channels.

2. Exclude individuals awaiting sentencing or under active legal obligations from appearing on national ballots.

3. Allow for exceptions for those whose convictions have been overturned, expunged, or pardoned.

Addressing Concerns

Some may argue that such laws restrict democratic participation. However, this legislation does not permanently bar individuals from running for office. Once voting rights are restored, and sentences are completed, individuals are free to participate fully in the democratic process. This strikes a balance between accountability and rehabilitation.

Elections should reflect the values and integrity of the democratic process. Prohibiting convicted felons who have lost their voting rights and not completed their sentences from appearing on national ballots is a necessary step toward ensuring fair representation and restoring public trust. It signals a commitment to ethics, accountability, and the principles of democracy. This legislation is not about exclusion—it’s about preserving the sanctity of the system and upholding the expectations Americans have for their leaders.

4o

Suggested Outline of Legislation

Model State Legislation: Prohibition of Convicted Felons Without Voting Rights on National Ballots

Section 1. Short TitleThis Act shall be known as the "Election Integrity and Accountability Act."

Section 2. Findings and Purpose(a) The legislature finds that:(1) Public trust in the electoral process is essential to a functioning democracy.(2) Individuals who have been convicted of felony offenses, have lost their voting rights, and have not completed their sentences or received sentencing should not appear on national ballots.

(b) The purpose of this Act is to ensure that candidates for federal office meet ethical and civic standards by requiring voting rights and sentence completion as prerequisites for ballot eligibility.

Section 3. DefinitionsFor the purposes of this Act:(a) "National ballot" refers to ballots for federal elections, including the offices of President, Vice President, U.S. Senator, and U.S. Representative.(b) "Convicted felon" refers to an individual convicted of a felony offense under state or federal law.(c) "Voting rights" refers to the restoration of an individual's eligibility to vote, either through completion of a sentence, clemency, or other legal processes.(d) "Sentence completion" refers to the conclusion of all judicially mandated obligations, including incarceration, probation, parole, and payment of fines or restitution.

Section 4. Prohibition on Placement of Ineligible Convicted Felons on National Ballots(a) No political party, candidate, or election official within the jurisdiction of this state may place the name of an individual on the ballot for any national office if:(1) The individual has been convicted of a felony and has lost their voting rights; and(2) The individual has not either:(A) Been sentenced by a court of law; or(B) Completed all obligations of their sentence, including incarceration, probation, parole, and payment of fines or restitution.

Section 5. Responsibilities of Election Officials(a) Election officials shall verify the criminal status and voting rights eligibility of all candidates seeking placement on the national ballot.(b) Any candidate found to be ineligible under this Act shall be disqualified from ballot placement.

Section 6. Penalties and Enforcement(a) Any election official who knowingly places an ineligible candidate on a national ballot shall be subject to civil penalties of up to $10,000 per violation.(b) Willful violations of this Act by election officials may result in removal from office or other disciplinary action as provided by state law.

Section 7. ExceptionsThis Act does not apply to:(a) Individuals whose felony convictions have been overturned or expunged.(b) Individuals who have received clemency or a pardon and have had their voting rights restored.

Section 8. Severability ClauseIf any provision of this Act is held invalid, the remaining provisions shall remain in effect.

Section 9. Effective DateThis Act shall take effect immediately upon enactment.